Pixar’s Elemental Fails To Ignite With Lowest Rating In Studio History

Discover The Controversy Surrounding Pixar’s Elemental As It Receives Its Lowest Rating In Studio History On Rotten Tomatoes.

By Amitabh Mukherji
May 29,2023
Featured Image

Pixar’s Elemental, directed by Peter Sohn of The Good Dinosaur fame, has recently set a record on Rotten Tomatoes. The film, set to release on June 16, tells the story of Ember and Wade, two opposite elements who find love in Element City.

Mixed Early Reviews At Cannes

Pixar’s Elemental

Prior to its theatrical release, Disney and Pixar showcased Elemental at the Cannes Film Festival. The response from critics was varied, leading to mixed early reviews and a record-breaking rating, similar to Lucasfilm’s Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny.

Pixar Makes History On Rotten Tomatoes

Pixar’s Elemental

Following its debut at Cannes, Pixar’s twenty-seventh film, Elemental, currently holds a 57% critical approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. This rating marks the lowest score for a Pixar film that is neither a sequel nor part of an established franchise.

Critics acknowledged Elemental’s creativity, heart, and stunning visuals, which are trademarks of Pixar. However, they also described the film as “heavy-handed” and a “misfire.” Even the positive reviews suggested that the film didn’t reach the top-tier caliber expected of Pixar.

Comparing Ratings: Elemental vs. Other Pixar Films

Pixar’s Elemental

A Bug’s Life: 92%

Luca: 91%

Onward: 88%

Monsters University: 80%

Brave: 79%

The Good Dinosaur: 75%

Lightyear: 74%

Cars: 75%

Cars 3: 68%

Cars 2: 40%

It’s important to note that Elemental’s current rating is based on only seven reviews and is likely to change in the coming weeks.

Elemental’s Reception Among Pixar Fans

Pixar’s Elemental

While Elemental’s current rating is based on a limited number of reviews, it is still worth noting as it is a first for Pixar. Rotten Tomatoes’ evaluation has always been a subject of controversy, but it provides an initial critical impression.

Although audiences will gain a clearer understanding of the film’s reception in the near future, these early reviews suggest that Elemental lives up to Pixar’s visual standards but falls short in terms of originality in its storytelling.